NOTE: Today’s book review was inspired by another book entitled Letters. That book was a memoir of scientist and storyteller Dr. Oliver Sacks, told through a lifetime of his personal correspondence with friends, family, patients and many other interesting people. Over the course of his letter writing, Dr. Sacks often made reference to the written works of others. Today’s book is an example of one such work that he referenced.
The Context in Which Dr. Sacks Made Reference to Another Country by James Baldwin
***For the sixth (and final) time in the same letter between Dr. Sacks and his friends Jonathan and Rachel Miller, Sacks makes a literary reference. This time, instead of making the reference with regard to the Millers, Oliver Sacks decided to close his letter by updating his friends on what books he had been reading for pleasure.

Here is a short summary of the whole letter:
In August of 1963, Oliver Sacks wrote a letter to his friend Jonathan Miller and Miller’s wife, Rachel. In 1963, Miller had resigned his position in the comedy troupe Beyond the Fringe and was laying the groundwork for a move into the world of theatrical directing. Beyond the Fringe had been achieving a great deal of success up until this point and had moved to London to continue their work in a larger market when Miller had stepped aside. All throughout this transitional period, Miller and Sacks had kept in touch via letters and phone calls. As was always the case with these two friends, Sacks was highly supportive of his friend and encouraged him to pursue his ambitions and broaden the scope of his creative expression. In today’s portion of the letter, Dr. Sacks ends his advice to Miller and begins to fill his friend in on what he had been reading lately. It is while doing so that Sacks says the following:
“Baldwin: wow! In grain, in literary and intellectual texture, second only to Faulkner. At best, magnificent but patchy.” – Oliver Sacks, Page #65, Letters.
A Brief Summary of Another Country by James Baldwin
Another Country was published in 1962 and immediately became one of the most highly censored/banned books in the entire world. The reason for this says much about the times in which the book came to life. Another Country examines the lives of its characters in terms of the societal baggage they carry because of their skin colour, sexual orientation, gender, nationality and so on. There are many scenes of explicit sexuality between male characters or between characters of different skin colours. All throughout this book, the characters search for love and happiness and personal contentment, only to be thwarted by the societal boundaries imposed upon them so capriciously by others and, if truth be told, by themselves and their lived experiences. The title of Another Country refers to a mythical imagined placed somewhere else far from where each character finds themselves, where they may be free to be who they truly are without fallout.
This book was written by Baldwin in New York City, Paris and Istanbul over the course of several years and, as a result, his writing style ebbs and flows in intensity and forcefulness. Another Country, in its final published form, is organized into three parts. In the first part, we meet a musician from Harlem named Rufus Scott. Rufus is a black bisexual man who ends up in a tumultuous relationship with a white woman from the Deep South. In time, the violence of their shared cultural history becomes too much, leading his lady to being institutionalized and leading Rufus to committing suicide. The rest of the book examines the fallout of that suicide on the lives of Rufus’ friends and family. In doing so, Baldwin gets to showcase the many ways in which societal mores come to be barriers to happiness and fulfillment. There is no real happy ending in this book. In the end, there is just life.
My Take on Another Country by James Baldwin (for what that is worth)
I was happy to have been given the opportunity to read a book by James Baldwin. One of the benefits (for me) of reading my way through the library of Dr. Oliver Sacks, is that I am finally finding the motivation to read the work of writers I have long admired but, up until now, never read. In many ways, this series is my version of “reading the classics” and, as it turned out in this case, I thoroughly enjoyed it!

James Baldwin is an award winning intellectual and writer who is highly celebrated for his examinations of race in America. In this age of social media clips and sound bites, I have watched and listened to Mr. Baldwin speak on all manner of issues dealing with being a black person in this world of ours. He is extremely well-spoken and possesses such a nimble and expansive mind that those who have dared to enter into a debate with him have usually emerged terribly scathed from the encounter.
As mentioned earlier in this post, Another Country was banned in many countries around the world upon its publication. I am quite certain that in the button-down world that was 1962 in North America, that my own parents would have found Baldwin’s explicit descriptions of carnality between male characters, between white characters and black characters and, finally, between characters who are married and characters who are not, to have been shocking and beyond the pale. But, the passing of time has done much to limit our ability to be shocked by anything anymore. I read Baldwin’s entire book and took in every scene as it came upon the page. There was nothing in Another Country that I haven’t seen played out in movies, television shows or other books already. Thus, the impact of the salacious nature of the book’s reputation was blunted for me. As such, I read this book more for the quality of its writing and for the ideas it contained. How Baldwin dressed up his lessons didn’t matter as much to me in the end.
I thoroughly enjoyed Baldwin’s writing style. He is good at writing believable character dialogue, as well as, setting scenes within scenes in ways that show the consequences of earlier action upon the current/future lives of his characters. I even saw myself dissected upon the pages of this book. In my own social media posts, along with my blog postings, I have, at one time or another, made mention of how enriched I feel my life has become because of my connections with people who have lived experiences that are different from my own. I have many friends who are women, as well as friends who are lesbians or homosexuals, jews, catholics, muslims, people of colour, immigrants to my country and so on. While I am not a deliberate collector of cultural characters, I have always viewed myself as being more openminded about lifestyles that are different than my own. My privilege as a straight white male has always shown up at times like this when I inevitably would say something along the lines that these friends and acquaintances are more than the sum of their heritage and lifestyles choices to me, they are all simply good people, whose company I enjoy and whose differences from me help me learn and grow as a person as a result. As James Baldwin shows in Another Country, it is in large part the very dichotomy of living in a society that acknowledges cultural and gender divergences while, at the same time, enslaving people to remain trapped and suffocated by those very same cultural and gender roles that ultimately define and limit who we are. My privilege is that I get to be colour blind while my friends get to go through life being viewed as being coloured or gay or female or Jewish or whatever. That I remove the tag in my mind does not, in reality, remove the tag from my friends as they experience their world.
For Dr. Oliver Sacks, a gay, Jewish man, I imagine that Another Country spoke to him very deeply. For example, one of the nicest, warmest parts of the entire book was a section that dealt with two men named Yves and Eric and the love that they found with each other in Paris. That portion of the book gave the closest portrayal to real, true love that existed anywhere else in the book. The most poignant part of the whole Yves-Eric love story happened when Eric, an American actor, received word that he had won an important lead role in a play on Broadway and that he must return to New York. This news changes everything for the young lovers because it means leaving the more open and accepting world of Paris for the more puritanical world of America. Both men discuss what it means for Eric’s career prospects (and what that, in turn, means for the viability of building a life together that is financially stable) while, acknowledging that the comfort in which they presently live in Paris cannot be replicated with any certainty in New York. Moving from “another country” to a place like New York, that Baldwin writes as if every person there is a commodity and that their value only comes/is limited to the very nature of that commodity, is a risk that Yves and Eric acknowledge. They agree that Eric must go first and find them a home to call their own and that the younger Yves (who has never left France before) will follow in a month or so. The whole second half of Another Country plays out against a backdrop of Eric, newly returned to New York, building a new life out of the old one he fled after Rufus had killed himself, all the while, living in fear mixed with anticipation for the moment when Yves would come to join him. Life can be beautiful but it can also be a gamble. I would like to believe that as a young sexually active gay man in the early 1960s, Dr. Oliver Sacks would have taken much solace in the loving nature of the relationship Yves and Eric enjoyed in Paris while, at the same time, completely understanding the risks that came with being who he truly wanted to be as a gay man in America. As Baldwin writes about so eloquently in Another Country, you can find happiness and love in America but there is no such thing as freedom there.
Overall, I enjoyed Another Country by James Baldwin and would recommend it to anyone who enjoys character-driven stories that examine culture in all of its aspects. Many critics of James Baldwin accuse him of being overly angry and pessimistic about the nature of living in America as a black man. To me, Baldwin comes by his views honestly. His lived experiences were definitely different than anything I might encounter in the course of my day or my life. But I am lucky in that I can read a book like Another Country and simply marvel at Baldwin’s skill as a writer and storyteller. I am grateful to be able to say it that way. Who James Baldwin truly was is more complicated and nuanced than that and is, in fact, the whole point of his book. We like to believe that we are the authors of our own stories. Sometimes that is true but, more often than we might care to admit, it is not.
– The link to the official website for James Baldwin can be found here.
– The link to the official website for Dr. Oliver Sacks can be found here.
***As always, all original content contained within this post remains the sole property of the author. NO portion of this post shall be reblogged, copied or shared in any manner without the express written consent of the author. ©2026 http://www.tommacinneswriter.com

